Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones are leading examples of high-quality television programming, something that was not conceivable earlier. Sucking audiences into their respective worlds, both shows are at the top of their game but I can’t help but feel they are not on the same level. One show, in my opinion, has the upper hand. (Before going on I have to say I love both shows.)
Now, I know people who have watched Breaking Bad and those who have watched Game of Thrones but not many who have seen both and more importantly loved both enough to judge which is better. Quite obviously BB fans would defend the show against GoT fans and vice versa but I’d be very interested in finding what fans of both shows have to say. As for me, I am more inclined to say Breaking Bad is the better TV show.
I find that Breaking Bad serves better as binge-watching material. I had finished season 2 in a day, that was how gripped I was. When it came to Game of Thrones, I couldn’t watch more than 2 or 3 episodes a day. This made me question why that was.
Well, the most clear reason I could think of was the fact that in Breaking Bad the focus lies on a set group of characters and their stories are told better. Walt and Jesse’s journey across five seasons is fascinating to watch, blurring the lines between moral and immoral in ways very shows have. Mike, Saul and Gustavo Fring were amazing characters, so it’s not as if only the protagonists hold viewers interest.
On the other hand, I feel that in Game of Thrones, there are quite a lot of characters who have potential and sadly we don’t get to identify with them as much because they are killed off. While GoT fans argue that it is the fact that no character is safe makes the show that much more interesting, I feel the stories of certain deceased characters weren’t developed properly and ended up becoming merely pawns in the drama. Then there are quite a few characters who I’m just not interested in and their story arcs are something I fast forward. If I were being honest, the only characters I truly like are Robb, Jon, Daenerys and Tyrion. I don’t really care much for the others. (Yes, this also can be said of the books, not strictly the TV show.)
But what Game of Thrones does a remarkable job of is portraying what is written in the books so well. However, it’s very Freudian in its emphasis on violence and sex. At times, the nudity just seems overbearing in the first season and it decreases as the show progressed which was a relief. Breaking Bad doesn’t rely on sex and aggression for its drama to such an extent.
Also, the fact that Breaking Bad was written for television makes for better episode story arcs and cliffhangers. Game of Thrones as book series has to be broken down into ten episodes so some can be quite dragging especially when a character you look forward to seeing does not have many or any scenes. (Yes, I get very bored when Tyrion isn’t around.) I guess that’s why some GoT seasons aren’t as interesting.
That’s why I believe as a TV drama, Breaking Bad works better.